Warning: Spoilers ahead.
We all remember the shocking twist at the end of Stranger Things Season 1…
CBS Television Studios / Via youtube.com
Nancy chose Steve!
WTF???
Netflix / Via Twitter: @lipaxmendes
Most of us spent the first season hating Steve…
Classic ’80s jock doucheface.
Netflix / Via netflix.com
…but then he really turned it around.
HOW ARE WE SUPPOSED TO FEEL NOW?
Netflix / Via strangerthingsfan.tumblr.com
When all was said and done, we still leaned towards #TeamJonathan.
Despite his constant brooding and the creepy photograph incident.
Netflix / Via images.hellogiggles.com
They DID go through some serious shit together.
Bonded for lyfe.
Netflix / Via hypable.com
However, when we saw Nancy and Steve together on Christmas, we weren’t exactly mad.
They cute.
Netflix / Via nytimes.com
Then, Stranger Things 2 started and Steve seemed to be back to his old tricks.
Chill, dude.
Netflix / Via netflix.com
Nancy drunkenly told Steve she didn’t love him and things appeared to be donezo…
This is good. Maybe. I DON’T KNOW.
Netflix / Via netflix.com
…which paved the way for Nancy and Jonathan.
Jonathan went from watching Nancy make out with Steve to sharing a hotel room with her REAL QUICK.
Netflix / Via netflix.com
During their travels, a HUGE piece of info was revealed.
She waited for Jonathan for a MONTH before dating Steve?! THIS CHANGES EVERYTHING.
Netflix / Via netflix.com
Then, Murray called out their sexual tension…
Murray should get his own spin-off, tbh.
Netflix / Via netflix.com
…which led to a ~sexy~ hookup.
All is right in the world! Or is it?
Netflix / Via netflix.com
Turns out, Steve was back in Hawkins discovering his calling.
And the internet was here for it.
Netflix / Via netflix.com
His newfound relationship with Dustin was a friggin’ delight!
Name a more iconic duo… I’ll wait.
Netflix / Via thisisinsider.com
And now we feel bad for Steve!
Nancy, why don’t you love him like we do?!
Netflix / Via netflix.com
And we can’t choose an OTP!
I don’t want any of my babies to be hurt!
Netflix / Via hellogiggles.com
On one hand, Steve has the perfect hair…
They need to re-release Farrah Spray ASAP.
Netflix / Via vanityfair.com
…and he’s just fun to be around.
WHAT. A. RIOT.
Netflix / Via junkee.com
He’s also amazing with the kids!
Netflix / Via /www.netflix.com/watch/80144898
On the other hand, Jonathan is deep…
Talking Heads AND Vonnegut? Be still my heart.
Netflix / Via netflix.com
TriStar Pictures / Via moviefone.com
He’s also the best big brother in the world.
Netflix / Via netflix.com
It’s basically Sophie’s Choice.
Can’t they just be a throuple?!
Netflix / Via fandomxximagines.tumblr.com
Nancy APPEARS to have chosen Jonathan…
(For now.)
Netflix / Via netflix.com
…but do we agree?
I GENUINELY CAN’T DECIDE.
Netflix / Via hellogiggles.com