No one can top Gene Wilder’s performance in “Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory.”
Silly. Twisted. Funny. Bemused. Dark.
Johnny Depp came up short in 2005’s “Charlie and the Chocolate Factory,” also inspired by Roald Dahl’s beloved book.
Now, Timothée Chalamet plays the chocolatier in “Wonka,” a prequel with the good sense to not even try.
That, plus luring “Paddington” director Paul King to steer the ship, proved the best decisions behind the charming saga.
Chalamet plays a young Willy Wonka, eager to start his candy company in a big, unnamed city. His pure heart is no match for the crusty locals. Candy overlords don’t want the competition, and they sic the police on poor Willy.
Even worse?
A pair of scoundrels (Olivia Colman, Tom Davis) trick Willy into slaving away at their hotel (“Scrub, Scrub!”), threatening to derail the young man’s dreams for decades.
The wily young man will find a way, and it might include a few musical numbers.
Yes, “Wonka” is a musical, and while it won’t dislodge “The Greatest Showman” from anyone’s mind the songs are sweet and catchy. The choreography isn’t revelatory, but it perfectly suits the material and tone.
Chalamet’s voice is, well, adequate, and you’ll wish the filmmakers plucked a lesser-known star with an instrument worthy of the franchise.
Oh, well. That’s show biz!
Chalamet’s dramatic chops prove superior, even if you can sense how hard he’s working to conjure Willy’s whimsical nature.
The film’s villains are oversized and appropriately vile. Keegan-Michael Key scores a few chuckles as a cop addicted to sugary treats. Cue the outrage over his fat costume…
“Wonka’s” secret weapon is Hugh Grant as, wait for it, an Oompa Loompa. The CGI required to make Grant Loompa-sized is seamless and leaves us with a crooked grin on our faces.
Grant can do no wrong these days, and he deserves more screen time.
Chalamet’s Wonka bears a heavy burden despite his cheery exterior. He misses his sweet Mum (Sally Hawkins) who taught him everything he knows about chocolate making. The subplot adds some grit to the story, suggesting the Wonka antihero we’ll meet in Wilder’s 1971 films.
Otherwise, there’s little connective tissue from this Wonka to the real cinematic deal. That doesn’t mean “Wonka” ignores the source material. You’ll hear some musical callbacks to the original film along with dialogue meant to fire up our nostalgia circuits.
“Strike that. Reverse it.”
Cute. Much like “Wonka.”
HiT or Miss: “Wonka” is a welcome surprise, a prequel that neither taints the source material nor disappoints hardcore fans.
The post ‘Wonka’ Ignores Gene Wilder, Crafts Spry Origin Story appeared first on Hollywood in Toto.